mtg pirate themed cards Magic: the Gathering 60-Card Theme Deck Pirates of the Caribbean Magic:

If they control Izzet Staticaster and you dont, then Phantasmal Image might be a good choice

Bruna is a little spicier, with an on-cast reanimation trigger

While this direct damage is nice, Omnath allows each land you play to provide additional value, as whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you can buff an Elemental you control with a +1/+1 counter even drawing a card if you've accumulated enough land

Sorceries (2)

Your goal is to quest with your characters as often as possible to maintain a lore lead on your opponent throughout the entire game while using those control tools to slow them down

Protection Magic AND Ultimate Magic: Holy Next up at our two-spot are two instants that protect your stuff