Honestly, even if we just see this card as two-mana for Lightshield Array and an opponent gains 3-5 life, thats still more than playable
For example, if you choose protection from Demons and from Dragons (totally counts), you can't choose protection from red later that day
While I cannot easily put a value on a card I can perhaps at least convince you that part of the value of drawing a card has absolutely nothing to do with what that card is or does
Chinese rectangular cards and round cards were used in India
Whereas most preconstructed Commander decks Wizards release are a solid four or five out of ten, Edgar represented an untuned deck that can often outplay a tuned deck simply because each creature in the deck represented two bodies
First, I love enchantments in general and I was floored by this utterly unique innovation in the card type that played heavily to its strengths